Showing posts with label CAnswers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CAnswers. Show all posts

Wednesday, 9 November 2022

What Is God? - Dr. Kevin Vost - Answering the World's Most Important Question

What Is God? 
Answering the World's Most Important Question
Dr. Kevin Vost
Catholic Answers
ISBN 
781683572947
eISBN 9781683572961
ASIN B0BGSNQJ8H


This is the 14th volume that I have from the masterful pen of Dr. Kevin Vost. At least three of Dr. Vost’s earlier books that I have read are about Saint Thomas Aquinas, and to some extend all of his memorization books do as well. As soon as I saw this book I got a copy and got to reading it. I have a Religious Studies Degree with a specialization in Roman Catholic Thought. I would have loved to have had the books by Dr. Vost as resources back then, or during my time working in Campus Ministry. This is another great read, it is an excellent offering from Dr Kevin Vost. The description of the volume is:

“Have you ever tried to have a close, loving relationship with someone you don’t know? It’s not easy. (And it’s probably not a good idea!)

Most would never dream of attempting such intimacy with a human stranger, yet many of us try to do just that with God! But just as with people, if we don’t know God, we can’t love him.

In What Is God?, Kevin Vost (Memorize the Reasons!) shows you how you can better know the most worthy object of our love, following the thought of the great theologian who first asked that question as a young boy: St. Thomas Aquinas.

That thirteenth-century Dominican friar later devoted much of his masterwork, the Summa Theologica, to exploring God in his deepest essence. But if you don’t have time to read a 1.8-million-word philosophical treatise translated from medieval Latin, Dr. Vost is here to break down the key parts for you. In clear and approachable fashion, What Is God examines God’s attributes and considers questions about him that have vexed mankind for centuries.

What does it mean for God to be simple? To be perfect?
Is God really knowable, after all?
Can we say that he is happy?
Is God able to change the past, or cause it not to have been?
And the classic: Can God make a boulder so big that even he cannot lift it?

St. Thomas has an answer for all of these, and many more . . . and What Is God? is the first book to collect and explain those answers in one place for modern readers.”

The chapters in this volume are:

Introduction: What Is the World’s Greatest Question?
Part I What Is the Study of God?  
 1 The Sacred Science of Theology
Part II Is There a God to Study?  
 2 How We Can Know God Exists
Part III What Is God?  
 Prologue
 3 God Is Simple
 4 God Is Perfect
 5 What Good Is
 6 God Is Good
 7 God Is Infinite
 8 God Exists in Things
 9 God Is Changeless
 10 God Is Eternal
 11 God Is One
 12 God Is Knowable
 13 God Has Names
Part IV What Does God Know?  
 14 God’s Knowledge
 15 God’s Ideas
 16 God Is Truth
 17 God and Falsity
Part V How Does God Live (and Love)?  
 18 God’s Life
 19 God’s Will
 20 God Is Love
 21 God’s Justice and Mercy
 22 God’s Providence
 23 God and Predestination
 24 God Writes the Book of Life
 25 God’s Power
 26 God’s Divine Happiness
Conclusion: Who Is God?
Appendix A: Attributes of God as Classified by John of St. Thomas
Appendix B: God Is . . . Master Summary List
About the Author
Endnotes

Vost writs in a very engaging manner. And he is a master of the subject matter, he has written on the good doctor several times. This volume is different in that it is primarily focused on the one question St. Thomas Aquinas answer. But it is just a tipping of the toe in the waters of Thomastic thought. Vost informs us:

“Here at the end of Thomas’s twenty-six questions on the existence and nature of God in the unity of his divine essence, we have reached only page 143 of the Summa Theologica in the English-only translation I use (albeit in rather small double-columned print). That leaves us with 2,868 pages to go!” 

Vost does an excellent job of this style of question and answer book. He draws from years of readying and study and synthesises down the material. This is a great volume for believers to know about whom we have a relationship. And to be able to answer those who come to us with questions.  

This volume is an excellent read. I can easily recommend this volume.

I have benefited from all the books from the skilled pen of Dr. Vost that I have read. Dr Vost has done an excellent job with this topic, and I am certain all who read this book will come away with a clearer understanding of the material. 

This is an excellent volume a great read!

Note: This book is part of a series of reviews: 2022 Catholic Reading Plan

For All reviews of books by Dr. Vost click here.

Books by Dr. Kevin Vost:
Full Range of Motive (2001)
Memorize the Faith! (2006)
Fit For Eternal Life (2007)
From Atheism to Catholicism (2010)
Unearthing Your Ten Talents (2010)
St. Albert the Great (2011)
Tending the Temple (2011)
Three Irish Saints (2012)
Memorize the Reasons! (2013)
One-Minute Aquinas (2014)
Hounds of the Lord (2015)
Seven Deadly Sins (2015)
Memorize the Mass! (2016)
Seven Gifts of the Holy Spirit (2016)
The Porch and the Cross (2016)
The Catholic Guide to Loneliness (2017)
The Four Friendships (2018)
How to Think Like Aquinas (2018)
Memorize the Latin Mass! (2018)
12 Life Lessons from St. Thomas Aquinas (2019)

Aquinas on the Four Last Things (2021)

Books Contributed to:
Man Up! (2014)


Author profile interview with Dr. Kevin Vost.





Monday, 4 April 2022

20 Answers St Thomas Aquinas - Dr. Kevin Vost - 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers

20 Answers: St Thomas Aquinas
20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers
Dr. Kevin Vost
Catholic Answers Press
ISBN 9781683572701
eISBN 9781683572725
eISBN 9781683572718
ASIN B09T8YFRT8


This is the 33rd volume in the Catholic Answers 20 Answers series that I have read and it is the 13th from the masterful pen of Dr. Kevin Vost. At least three of Dr Vost’s earlier books that I have read are about Saint Thomas Aquinas, and to some extend all of his memorization books do as well. As soon as I saw this book I got a copy and got to reading it.

I love the books in the 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers. I often recommended specific books or the whole series to many friends and family members. Both to those with questions, and for those looking to be able to answer the questions of others.  A few years ago I started with the 20 Answers Challenge when there were just 20 books in the series, at the time. I have benefited from each that I have read in the series. Each one has been educational, informative and has encouraged my faith. I have a Religious Studies Degree with a specialization in Roman Catholic Thought. I would have loved to have had these books as resources back then, or during my time working in Campus Ministry. They are great reads, and this is an excellent offering from Dr Kevin Vost. The description of the volume is:

“Who was Thomas Aquinas, and why is he such a big deal?

How does St. Thomas prove the existence of God by reason alone?

What is the Summa Theologica, and what are its major parts, topics, and arguments?

How can Thomistic teachings on theology, philosophy, morals, and prayer help us become better Christians?

The portly thirteenth-century Dominican friar Thomas Aquinas lived less than fifty years, but during that time he became one of the greatest theologians in the history of the Catholic Church—and one of the greatest minds in the history of the world. 20 Answers: St. Thomas Aquinas offers a handy and accessible introduction to the life and thought of this intellectual and spiritual giant, breaking down key themes of his writing and offering a ground-floor lesson on the faithful synthesis of Catholic teaching and classical philosophy that became known as “Thomism”.”

The description of the series is:

“The 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers offers hard facts, powerful arguments, and clear explanations of the most important topics facing the Church and the world—all in a compact, easy-to-read package. Check out dozens of other topics in the 20 Answers Series of booklets published by Catholic Answers Press.”

The questions answered in this volume are:

1. Who is St. Thomas Aquinas?
2. What is the Summa Theologica (or is it Summa Theologiae)?
3. What is the role of Scripture in theology?
4. Is God’s existence self-evident?
5. Can God’s existence be proven through reason?
6. What are St. Thomas’s five ways to prove the existence of God?
7. What is God?
8. Who is God?
9. What is the relationship between faith and reason?
10. How are human beings made in God’s image and likeness?
11. What is the key to human happiness?
12. What are virtues, and how do we build them?
13. How did St. Thomas establish himself as a “medieval memory master”?
14. What does St. Thomas teach us about the gifts of the Holy Spirit?
15. How is Jesus Christ both the way and the destination?
16. Was St. Thomas ever wrong?
17. How can a Thomistic approach lead non-Catholics to the Church?
18. How can St. Thomas help us pray with greater devotion?
19. Why was St. Thomas called one of his century’s greatest poets?
20. Why does the world need St. Thomas now?

The beginning of the introduction to this volume states:

“Why a booklet of answers about St. Thomas Aquinas? Well, in his day Thomas answered all sorts of essential questions facing the Catholic Church and the world that remain relevant in our day. Indeed, in his greatest work, Thomas gave 2,669 answers about the Faith in more than 1.5 million words!”

And further on it states:

“Thomas would become perhaps the greatest human guide in all the Church’s history, blessed with a powerful intellect and an admirable openness to God’s grace. Further, he borrowed from, compiled, analyzed, synthesized, and made wonderful sense of the greatest insights of the philosophers, theologians, saints, and Church Fathers and Doctors who had come before him. To read Thomas is to read dozens of Eastern and Western theologians, each duly noted and directly quoted. Indeed, St. Cajetan would say Thomas so venerated the great thinkers who came before him that he “inherited the intellect of them all.”

There are many humorous stories of Thomas as the quintessential “absent-minded professor,” always absorbed in thought. One time, he had a deep insight, slammed his massive fist upon a table, and shouted, “That will settle the Manichees!”2 The problem was, he had forgotten that he was seated at a dinner hosted by Louis IX, the French king. Louis—also to become a saint—simply asked someone to bring some paper so Thomas’s insight would not be lost! 

Thomas answered thousands of questions for the Catholic faithful. For us, twenty will have to suffice—but remember that this brief booklet is intended only to scratch the surface of the life and work of one of the Church’s greatest theologians and an intellectual giant among our Catholic ancestors. St. Thomas, pray for us!”

When I was in university, I was involved with Campus Crusade for Christ, there was a series of booklets by the founder Bill Bright, called Transferable Concepts, and by reading them many times you could almost memorize them and the message so that you could share it. This book and this series are along those lines. For most books in this series you can easily work through this book in a few of sessions, this volume however would take a little more time and effort. But the results would be well worth the work. It will really solidify the teaching in your own mind and heart. And thus be able to answer questions from non-Christians, non-Catholics and even other Catholics. A sample chapter from this work is:

“8. Who is God? 

In the first twenty-six questions of the Summa, St. Thomas uses natural reasoning to determine what creation can tell us about its creator. Reason tells us there is only one God, who is being itself—simple, perfect, unchangeable, all-powerful, and all-knowing. But this God himself, through revelation, has told us also that in a marvelous way, he is three. Thomas believed that God’s triune nature cannot be proved by reason alone. Indeed, in the same article, he states, “Whoever, then, tries to prove the Trinity of the persons by natural reason, derogates from faith in two ways.” 

First off, to attempt to prove the Trinity by reason alone slights the dignity of faith, because faith pertains to “things that appear not” (Heb. 1:1)—that is, to invisible, spiritual things that surpass the powers of our reason. Second, such arguments are not useful in drawing non-believers to the Faith, since they are not conclusive in themselves and can lead non-believers to ridicule us if they come to think we believe in the Trinity because of such arguments. 

Our reasoning about the Trinity, then, is not to provide sufficient proof of the Trinity, but only to show that our belief in the Triune God is not self-contradictory, is not impossible, and is reasonable—although never completely understandable to us. Our knowledge of the Trinity also moves us from the realm of what God is into the even more fascinating realm of who he is. 

Although the word Trinity does not appear in Scripture, multiple passages make clear that God is triune and that from the Father proceed the Son and the Holy Spirit. As for the Son, “Our Lord says, ‘From God I proceeded’” (John 8:42). Thomas says that when we reason about the Trinity, we must consider three fundamental issues: first, the origin or procession of the persons; second, their relations; and third, the persons themselves. 

The Son and the Holy Spirit proceed from the Father not by means of an external, outward act like that of creation. Their procession is an inward act within God. Procession in God is akin in a way to procession in the human intellect. For example, when we understand a thing in our intellect, a concept comes forth from our intellectual power and proceeds from our knowledge of that object. A speaker can say a word and retain its meaning within himself. We know things imperfectly, and we can generate words about them. God’s divine intelligence, by contrast, is perfect, such that “the divine Word is of necessity perfectly one with the source whence he proceeds” (ST, I, Q. 27, a. 1). 

After all, as we read in John 1:1: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.” This proceeding of the Word or Son of God from the Father, akin to our acts of knowing, is called generation. The Word proceeds from the Father’s perfect and total knowing, somewhat like the way our concepts and words proceed from our imperfect, partial manner of knowing. 
Our intellects are one way we were formed in the image and likeness of God, but they’re not the only way. The other way lies in our possession of will. 
“The operation of the will within ourselves,” Thomas writes, “involves also another procession, that of love, whereby the object loved is in the lover; as, by the conception of the word, the object spoken of or understood is in the intelligent agent. Hence, besides the procession of the Word in God, there exists in him another procession called the procession of love” (ST, I, Q. 27, a. 3). 

This procession of love flows from the procession of the Word, since nothing can be loved unless it is known by the intellect. We call this procession of love the Holy Spirit, and every time we recite the Nicene Creed at Mass, we declare that we believe in the Holy Spirit, “who proceeds from the Father and the Son.” 

As for the relations of the Holy Trinity, relationships exist when two or more distinct things can be referred to or contrasted in some way relative to each other. The Father generates the Son, and this relation is called paternity. The Son is begotten by the Father, and this relation is called filiation. 

The relation of the principle of procession of love is called spiration, which derives from our words for “breathing” and for “spirit.” The Father and Son spirate the Holy Spirit. The opposite relation, that of the spirated Holy Spirit to the Father and the Son, is called procession. These, then, are the four sublime relations between the persons of the threeness of the oneness that is the Holy Trinity: paternity, filiation, spiration, and procession. 

As for the persons of the Trinity, the early sixth-century philosopher Boethius defined a person as “an individual substance of a rational nature” (ST, I, Q. 29, a. 1). The only persons of all creatures on earth are human beings. So how is God a person—let alone three? 

Thomas answers, “Person signifies what is most perfect in all nature—that is, a subsistent individual with a rational nature” (a. 3). Hence, “since everything that is perfect must be attributed to God, forasmuch as his essence contains every perfection, this name person is fittingly applied to God—not, however, as it is applied to creatures, but in a more excellent way.” Although the word person is not found applied to God in Scripture, what that word means is found many times, because God is regularly described, as Thomas puts it, as “the supreme, self-subsisting and the most perfectly intelligent being.” 

As for the three persons of the Trinity, Thomas agrees with St. Augustine that the Father is the “principle of the whole deity” (ST, I, Q. 33, a. 1), unbegotten and proceeding from no other principle. He notes as well that we sometimes use the name Father, not as the name of the person, but to refer to the whole Trinity.

As for the Son, the Word of God is his personal name, but we must never forget that he is of the same substance as the Father. He is also called the image of God. Man is made in the image of God, whereas the Son alone is the actual image of God. 
The Holy Spirit shares important things in common with the Father and Son—for example, that they are spirits and that they are holy. But Thomas also notes that the Holy Spirit can fittingly be named Love, because “the Holy Ghost is said to be the bond of the Father and the Son, inasmuch as he is Love” (ST, I, Q. 37, a. 1).”

That sample chapter will server to give you a feel for this work. This is one of the most academic of the volumes I have read. But that is to be expected based on the subject matter and the author. Yet It is a book anyone frim high school age or education and up could pick up, read, and benefit from. Vost however does not write a dry treatise or 20 questions and answers. The book is very engaging, at times humorous. And most importantly of all just solid teaching! 

This volume is a fantastic read. Even being familiar with the subject, and with Dr Vost’s works on the subject I greatly benefited from reading this work, and know I will return and read it again. I highly recommend this volume.

I have benefited from all the books in this series that I have read. Dr Vost has done an excellent job with this topic, and I am certain all who read this book will come away with a clearer understanding of the Ox. 

This is an excellent volume a great read in a wonderful series!

Note: This book is part of a series of reviews: 2022 Catholic Reading Plan

For all reviews of 20 Answers books click here.
For All reviews of books by Dr. Vost click here.


Books by Dr. Kevin Vost:
Full Range of Motive (2001)
Memorize the Faith! (2006)
Fit For Eternal Life (2007)
From Atheism to Catholicism (2010)
Unearthing Your Ten Talents (2010)
St. Albert the Great (2011)
Tending the Temple (2011)
Three Irish Saints (2012)
Memorize the Reasons! (2013)
One-Minute Aquinas (2014)
Hounds of the Lord (2015)
Seven Deadly Sins (2015)
Memorize the Mass! (2016)
Seven Gifts of the Holy Spirit (2016)
The Porch and the Cross (2016)
The Catholic Guide to Loneliness (2017)
The Four Friendships (2018)
How to Think Like Aquinas (2018)
Memorize the Latin Mass! (2018)
12 Life Lessons from St. Thomas Aquinas (2019)

Aquinas on the Four Last Things (2021)

Books Contributed to:
Man Up! (2014)


Author profile interview with Dr. Kevin Vost.

20 Answers Series:
20 Answers Abortion - Trent Horn
20 Answers Angels & Demons - Fr. Mike Driscoll
20 Answers Atheism - Matt Fradd
20 Answers Death & Judgement - Trent Horn
20 Answers Divorce & Remarriage - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers End of Life - Jason Negri
20 Answers Faith & Science - Trent Horn
20 Answers God - Trent Horn
20 Answers Islam - Andrew Blezad
20 Answers Jehovah's Witnesses - Trent Horn
20 Answers Mary - Tim Staples
20 Answers Miracles - Karlo Broussard
20 Answers Mormonism - Trent Horn
20 Answers Salvation - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Scripture and Tradition - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Bible - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Eucharist - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Papacy - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Real Jesus - Trent Horn

20 Answers The Church - Trent Horn
20 Answers Witchcraft & the Occult - Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Apparitions & Revelations - Michael O'Neill
20 Answers Bible Prophecy - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Homosexuality - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Sacraments - Fr. Mike Driscoll

20 Answers Bible Difficulties - Jimmy Akin  
20 Answers The Reformation - Steve Weidenkopf
20 Answers Bioethics - Stacy A. Trasancos
20 Answers Conversion - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Faith and Works - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers: Relics & Sacramentals - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Anti-Catholic Myths - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The End Times - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The Rosary - Tom Nash
20 Answers Seasons & Feasts – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers New Age -  Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Catholic Social Teaching – Mark Brumley
20 Answers Prayer – Hugh Barbour O. Praem and Sebastian Walshe O. Praem
20 Answers Faith & Reason – Christopher Kaczor
20 Answers The New Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Protestantism – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Marriage & Sex – Todd Aglialoro
20 Answers The Early Church – Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Old Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Judaism – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers The Sacraments – Father Mike Driscoll
...  

Other Books from Catholic Answers:
Hard Sayings: A Catholic Approach to Answering Bible Difficulties - Trent Horn
A Daily Defense: Apologetics Lessons for Every Day - Jimmy Akin
The Apostasy That Wasn't: The Extraordinary Story of the Unbreakable Early Church - Rod Bennett
Answering Atheism - How to Make the Case for God with Logic and Charity - Trent Horn
Persuasive Pro Life: How to Talk About Our Culture's Toughest Issue - Trent Horn and Fr Frank Pavone
The Protestant's Dilemma: How the Reformation's Shocking Consequences Point to the Truth of Catholicism - Devin Rose
Behold Your Mother: A Biblical and Historical Defense of the Marian Doctrines - Tim Staples
Handed Down: The Catholic Faith of the Early Christians - James L. Papandrea
Demons, Deliverance, Discernment: Separating Fact from Fiction about the Spirit World - Fr. Mike Driscoll
Navigating the Tiber: How to Help Your Friends and Family Journey Toward the Catholic Faith - Devin Rose
100 Biblical Arguments Against Sola Scriptura - Dave Armstrong
The Drama of Salvation: How God Rescues You from Your Sins and Brings You to Eternal Life - Jimmy Akin
The Truth is Out There (Brendan and Erc in Exile Book 1 - Brother Amadeus and Amadeus
...Memorize the Reasons! Defending the Faith with the Catholic Art of Memory - Kevin Vost
Marching Orders: A Tactical Plan for Converting the World to Christ - Dan McGuire

The Fathers Know Best - Jimmy Akin
Why We're Catholic: Our Reasons for Faith, Hope, and Love - Trent Horn
The Old Evangelization: How to Spread the Faith Like Jesus Did - Eric Sammons
What the Saints Never Said - Trent Horn
...


Sunday, 26 December 2021

20 Answers Eastern Catholicism - Daniel Dozier - 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers

20 Answers: The Communion of Saints
20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers
Fr. Dcn. Daniel Dozier
Catholic Answers Press
ISBN 9781683571599
eISBN 9781683571612
eISBN 9781683571605
ASIN B083PTHCXC


I love the books in the 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers. I have read books in the 20 Answers series over 30 times, a few of them multiple times and some of them just once. I have recommended many to friends and family. Both to those with questions, and For those looking to be able to answer the questions of others.  A few years ago I started with the 20 Answers Challenge when there were just 20 books in the series, at the time. I have benefited from each that I have read in the series, and have recommended many to friends and family so often. And each one has been educational, informative and has encouraged my faith. I have a Religious Studies Degree with a specialization in Roman Catholic Thought. I would have loved to have had these books as resources back then, or during my time working in Campus Ministry. They are great reads, and this is an excellent offering from Father Daniel Dozier. The description of the volume is:

“What is it like to visit and worship at an Eastern Catholic parish?

How can there be many different “churches” in the one Catholic Church?

What are some aspects of Eastern Catholic theology and practice that differ from the West?

The rich history and theological, liturgical, and artistic traditions of the twenty-three Eastern Catholic churches are such an indispensable part of the global Catholic communion that, along with the Latin West, these churches are said to form one of the two “lungs” by which the Church breathes and lives. Yet even though Pope St. John Paul II called on the faithful to appreciate the treasures of the Christian East, far too many Catholics remain ignorant of them. 20 Answers: Eastern Catholicism provides an invaluable primer, explaining the origins of the Eastern Catholic churches and how they fit into the one Church of Christ, their distinctive prayers and practices, and some of the common misunderstandings and controversies that even today can cause unnecessary division and confusion.”

The description of the series is:

“The 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers offers hard facts, powerful arguments, and clear explanations of the most important topics facing the Church and the world—all in a compact, easy-to-read package. Check out dozens of other topics in the 20 Answers Series of booklets published by Catholic Answers Press.”

The questions answered in this volume are:

1. Doesn’t the Bible say all Christians are saints?
2. How does someone become a saint?
3. Can someone stop being a saint?
4. Are there non-Catholic saints?
5. Doesn’t praying to saints make gods out of them?
6. Doesn’t the Catholic practice of asking the saints to pray for us contradict 1 Timothy 2:5?
7. Why would we seek the help of saints when we can go straight to Jesus?
8. What about Deuteronomy 18:10–12, which forbids communicating with the dead?
9. How can the saints in heaven intercede for us when the Bible says in Ecclesiastes that they aren’t conscious or don’t know anything?
10. How can the saints in heaven intercede for us when the Bible says God alone knows the hearts of men?
11. Why should we believe that the saints are aware of our prayers when they don’t do anything to save us from harm in our lives?
12. Is there any evidence in the Bible that the saints pray for us?
13. Does the Bible ever instruct us to pray to the saints?
14. Do early Christian sources outside the New Testament affirm the intercession of the saints?
15. How can the Catholic Church approve of having statues when the Bible forbids graven images in Exodus 20:4–6?
16. What about bowing in front of statues?
17. Is the Catholic Church’s veneration of relics from the saints nothing but superstition?
18. What is the biblical basis for the distinction between dulia and latria?
19. Do I have to believe what a saint says in his writings or private revelations?
20. Must I have a devotion to the saints?

The beginning of the introduction to this volume states:

“In the opening remarks of his 1995 encyclical letter, Orientale Lumen (“Light of the East”), Pope St. John Paul II wrote: 

“Since, in fact, we believe that the venerable and ancient tradition of the Eastern churches is an integral part of the heritage of Christ’s Church, the first need for Catholics is to be familiar with that tradition, so as to be nourished by it and to encourage the process of unity in the best way possible for each.

Our Eastern Catholic brothers and sisters are very conscious of being the living bearers of this tradition, together with our Orthodox brothers and sisters. The members of the Catholic Church of the Latin tradition must also be fully acquainted with this treasure and thus feel, with the pope, a passionate longing that the full manifestation of the Church’s catholicity be restored to the Church and to the world.”

This booklet is my own small contribution in honor of the saintly pope’s desires that Latin Catholics in the West become familiar with their brothers and sisters of the Christian East, along with their rich treasures of liturgy, spirituality, theology, and disciplines. In this respect, they can come to appreciate more fully what it means to be Catholic.”

And further on it states:

“None of us is responsible for these historical divisions and issues. We have inherited a past we did not create, and yet we have an obligation to shape our present and our future through knowledge, charity, prayerful study, and encounter. In that way we might in fact realize the hope-filled aspirations of a pope whose own familial heritage was itself both Latin and Greek Catholic.

I hope that you find within these pages helpful answers as we walk together toward our true East: the New Jerusalem. May the light of Christ inspire us all to be united in truth and charity as faithful members of the holy Church of the nations.”

When I was in university, I was involved with Campus Crusade for Christ, there was a series of booklets by the founder Bill Bright, called Transferable Concepts, and by reading them many times you could almost memorize them and the message so that you could share it. This book and this series are along those lines. You can easily work through this book in a couple of short sessions. And you could work through it a few times. And solidify the teaching in your own mind and heart. And thus be able to answer questions from non-Christians, non-Catholics and even other Catholics. 

This volume was a fantastic read. I have covered the eastern traditions in several theology and church history courses, but this book took it to a deeper level. It really opened my eyes. It has helped me to see the eastern rights in a very different light. I highly recommend this volume.

I have benefited from all the books in this series that I have read. Father Dozier has done an excellent job with this topic, and I am certain all who read this book will come away with a clearer understanding of the Eastern Catholicism. 

This is an excellent volume a great read in a wonderful series!

Note: This book is part of a series of reviews: 2021 Catholic Reading Plan!


20 Answers Series:
20 Answers Abortion - Trent Horn
20 Answers Angels & Demons - Fr. Mike Driscoll
20 Answers Atheism - Matt Fradd
20 Answers Death & Judgement - Trent Horn
20 Answers Divorce & Remarriage - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers End of Life - Jason Negri
20 Answers Faith & Science - Trent Horn
20 Answers God - Trent Horn
20 Answers Islam - Andrew Blezad
20 Answers Jehovah's Witnesses - Trent Horn
20 Answers Mary - Tim Staples
20 Answers Miracles - Karlo Broussard
20 Answers Mormonism - Trent Horn
20 Answers Salvation - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Scripture and Tradition - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Bible - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Eucharist - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Papacy - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Real Jesus - Trent Horn

20 Answers The Church - Trent Horn
20 Answers Witchcraft & the Occult - Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Apparitions & Revelations - Michael O'Neill
20 Answers Bible Prophecy - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Homosexuality - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Sacraments - Fr. Mike Driscoll

20 Answers Bible Difficulties - Jimmy Akin  
20 Answers The Reformation - Steve Weidenkopf
20 Answers Bioethics - Stacy A. Trasancos
20 Answers Conversion - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Faith and Works - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers: Relics & Sacramentals - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Anti-Catholic Myths - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The End Times - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The Rosary - Tom Nash
20 Answers Seasons & Feasts – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers New Age -  Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Catholic Social Teaching – Mark Brumley
20 Answers Prayer – Hugh Barbour O. Praem and Sebastian Walshe O. Praem
20 Answers Faith & Reason – Christopher Kaczor
20 Answers The New Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Protestantism – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Marriage & Sex – Todd Aglialoro
20 Answers The Early Church – Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Old Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Judaism – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers The Sacraments – Father Mike Driscoll
...  

Other Books from Catholic Answers:
Hard Sayings: A Catholic Approach to Answering Bible Difficulties - Trent Horn
A Daily Defense: Apologetics Lessons for Every Day - Jimmy Akin
The Apostasy That Wasn't: The Extraordinary Story of the Unbreakable Early Church - Rod Bennett
Answering Atheism - How to Make the Case for God with Logic and Charity - Trent Horn
Persuasive Pro Life: How to Talk About Our Culture's Toughest Issue - Trent Horn and Fr Frank Pavone
The Protestant's Dilemma: How the Reformation's Shocking Consequences Point to the Truth of Catholicism - Devin Rose
Behold Your Mother: A Biblical and Historical Defense of the Marian Doctrines - Tim Staples
Handed Down: The Catholic Faith of the Early Christians - James L. Papandrea
Demons, Deliverance, Discernment: Separating Fact from Fiction about the Spirit World - Fr. Mike Driscoll
Navigating the Tiber: How to Help Your Friends and Family Journey Toward the Catholic Faith - Devin Rose
100 Biblical Arguments Against Sola Scriptura - Dave Armstrong
The Drama of Salvation: How God Rescues You from Your Sins and Brings You to Eternal Life - Jimmy Akin
The Truth is Out There (Brendan and Erc in Exile Book 1 - Brother Amadeus and Amadeus
...Memorize the Reasons! Defending the Faith with the Catholic Art of Memory - Kevin Vost
Marching Orders: A Tactical Plan for Converting the World to Christ - Dan McGuire

The Fathers Know Best - Jimmy Akin
Why We're Catholic: Our Reasons for Faith, Hope, and Love - Trent Horn
The Old Evangelization: How to Spread the Faith Like Jesus Did - Eric Sammons
What the Saints Never Said - Trent Horn
...


Saturday, 18 December 2021

20 Answers The Communion of Saints - Karlo Broussard - 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers

20 Answers: The Communion of Saints
20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers
Catholic Answers Press
ISBN 9781683572367
eISBN 9781683572381
eISBN 9781683572374
ASIN B096H8L743


I have read and I have read books in the 20 Answers series over 30 times. A few years ago I started with the 20 Answers Challenge when there were just 20 books in the series, at the time. I have benefited from each that I have read in the series, and have recommended many to friends and family. And each one has been educational, informative and has encouraged my faith. I have a Religious Studies Degree with a specialization in Roman Catholic Thought. I would have loved to have had these books as resources back then. They are great reads, and this is an excellent offering from Karlo Broussard. The description of the volume is:

“Doesn’t the Bible say we’re all saints?

How can the saints possibly hear the prayers of everyone on earth?

Isn’t praying to dead saints not only idolatrous but also the unbiblical practice of necromancy?

If Jesus is the “one mediator between God and men” (1 Tim. 2:5), isn’t it wrong to ask the saints to mediate for us with God?

Catholics believe that the souls of those who were saved by Jesus not only live forever in his presence, but that we who are still on earth have fellowship with them. This sense of solidarity with all those who live in Christ is ancient and unbroken—but it’s also a source of confusion and sometimes even hostility for non-Catholic Christians. 20 Answers: The Communion of Saints explains this beautiful Catholic teaching in a way that’s easy to understand and share, with solid biblical arguments dispelling many myths about our belief and practice regarding the saints.”

The description of the series is:

“The 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers offers hard facts, powerful arguments, and clear explanations of the most important topics facing the Church and the world—all in a compact, easy-to-read package. Check out dozens of other topics in the 20 Answers Series of booklets published by Catholic Answers Press.”

The questions answered in this volume are:

1. Doesn’t the Bible say all Christians are saints?
2. How does someone become a saint?
3. Can someone stop being a saint?
4. Are there non-Catholic saints?
5. Doesn’t praying to saints make gods out of them?
6. Doesn’t the Catholic practice of asking the saints to pray for us contradict 1 Timothy 2:5?
7. Why would we seek the help of saints when we can go straight to Jesus?
8. What about Deuteronomy 18:10–12, which forbids communicating with the dead?
9. How can the saints in heaven intercede for us when the Bible says in Ecclesiastes that they aren’t conscious or don’t know anything?
10. How can the saints in heaven intercede for us when the Bible says God alone knows the hearts of men?
11. Why should we believe that the saints are aware of our prayers when they don’t do anything to save us from harm in our lives?
12. Is there any evidence in the Bible that the saints pray for us?
13. Does the Bible ever instruct us to pray to the saints?
14. Do early Christian sources outside the New Testament affirm the intercession of the saints?
15. How can the Catholic Church approve of having statues when the Bible forbids graven images in Exodus 20:4–6?
16. What about bowing in front of statues?
17. Is the Catholic Church’s veneration of relics from the saints nothing but superstition?
18. What is the biblical basis for the distinction between dulia and latria?
19. Do I have to believe what a saint says in his writings or private revelations?
20. Must I have a devotion to the saints?

The beginning of the introduction to this volume states:

“After the doctrines surrounding the Virgin Mary, the Catholic doctrine of the intercession of the saints may elicit more challenges from Protestants than any other topic. These tend to be of two types.

Some challenges are based on the idea that it’s not appropriate for Christians to request that the saints pray for them: either it takes away from the uniqueness of Jesus’ mediation or God outright forbids it as an “abominable practice” (Deut. 18:12). Other challenges are more practical: some Protestants may think that, in principle, requesting that the saints pray for us could be appropriate, but it’s just futile to do so because the souls in heaven aren’t able to intercede for us.”

And further on it states:

“It’s important that we have adequate answers to queries from Catholics as well. Catholics need to know the truth about the saints, and all Catholics have been called by Christ to experience the graces that can flow from having healthy relationships with those fellow Christians who are perfected in him. They are our brothers and sisters. Together, we are the “household of God” (1 Tim. 3:15). I pray that this booklet will help you enjoy more fully the blessings of this great family.”

When I was in university, I was involved with Campus Crusade for Christ, there was a series of booklets by the founder Bill Bright, called Transferable Concepts, and by reading them many times you could almost memorize them and the message so that you could share it. This book and this series are along those lines. You can easily work through this book in a couple of short sessions. And you could work through it a few times. And solidify the teaching in your own mind and heart. And thus be able to answer questions from non-Christians, non-Catholics and even other Catholics. 

Over the last few years I have read many biographies of saints, most from the Catholic Truth Society. And I benefit from each of those books.  This volume helped me solidify clearer answers for friends and family who ask why I read so much about Saints. 

I have benefited from all the books in this series that I have read. Karlo has done an excellent job with this topic, and I am certain all who read this book will come away with a clearer understanding of the churches view on Saints. 

Another excellent volume a great read in a wonderful series!


Note: This book is part of a series of reviews: 2021 Catholic Reading Plan!


20 Answers Series:
20 Answers Abortion - Trent Horn
20 Answers Angels & Demons - Fr. Mike Driscoll
20 Answers Atheism - Matt Fradd
20 Answers Death & Judgement - Trent Horn
20 Answers Divorce & Remarriage - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers End of Life - Jason Negri
20 Answers Faith & Science - Trent Horn
20 Answers God - Trent Horn
20 Answers Islam - Andrew Blezad
20 Answers Jehovah's Witnesses - Trent Horn
20 Answers Mary - Tim Staples
20 Answers Miracles - Karlo Broussard
20 Answers Mormonism - Trent Horn
20 Answers Salvation - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Scripture and Tradition - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Bible - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Eucharist - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Papacy - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Real Jesus - Trent Horn

20 Answers The Church - Trent Horn
20 Answers Witchcraft & the Occult - Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Apparitions & Revelations - Michael O'Neill
20 Answers Bible Prophecy - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Homosexuality - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Sacraments - Fr. Mike Driscoll

20 Answers Bible Difficulties - Jimmy Akin  
20 Answers The Reformation - Steve Weidenkopf
20 Answers Bioethics - Stacy A. Trasancos
20 Answers Conversion - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Faith and Works - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers: Relics & Sacramentals - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Anti-Catholic Myths - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The End Times - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The Rosary - Tom Nash
20 Answers Seasons & Feasts – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers New Age -  Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Catholic Social Teaching – Mark Brumley
20 Answers Prayer – Hugh Barbour O. Praem and Sebastian Walshe O. Praem
20 Answers Faith & Reason – Christopher Kaczor
20 Answers The New Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Protestantism – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Marriage & Sex – Todd Aglialoro
20 Answers The Early Church – Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Old Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Judaism – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers The Sacraments – Father Mike Driscoll
... 

Other Books from Catholic Answers:
Hard Sayings: A Catholic Approach to Answering Bible Difficulties - Trent Horn
A Daily Defense: Apologetics Lessons for Every Day - Jimmy Akin
The Apostasy That Wasn't: The Extraordinary Story of the Unbreakable Early Church - Rod Bennett
Answering Atheism - How to Make the Case for God with Logic and Charity - Trent Horn
Persuasive Pro Life: How to Talk About Our Culture's Toughest Issue - Trent Horn and Fr Frank Pavone
The Protestant's Dilemma: How the Reformation's Shocking Consequences Point to the Truth of Catholicism - Devin Rose
Behold Your Mother: A Biblical and Historical Defense of the Marian Doctrines - Tim Staples
Handed Down: The Catholic Faith of the Early Christians - James L. Papandrea
Demons, Deliverance, Discernment: Separating Fact from Fiction about the Spirit World - Fr. Mike Driscoll
Navigating the Tiber: How to Help Your Friends and Family Journey Toward the Catholic Faith - Devin Rose
100 Biblical Arguments Against Sola Scriptura - Dave Armstrong
The Drama of Salvation: How God Rescues You from Your Sins and Brings You to Eternal Life - Jimmy Akin
The Truth is Out There (Brendan and Erc in Exile Book 1 - Brother Amadeus and Amadeus
...Memorize the Reasons! Defending the Faith with the Catholic Art of Memory - Kevin Vost
Marching Orders: A Tactical Plan for Converting the World to Christ - Dan McGuire

The Fathers Know Best - Jimmy Akin
Why We're Catholic: Our Reasons for Faith, Hope, and Love - Trent Horn
The Old Evangelization: How to Spread the Faith Like Jesus Did - Eric Sammons
What the Saints Never Said - Trent Horn
...


Sunday, 11 July 2021

20 Answers: Relics & Sacramentals - Shaun McAfee - 20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers

20 Answers: Relics & Sacramentals
20 Answers Series from Catholic Answers
Shaun McAfee
Catholic Answers Press
ISBN 9781683572398
eISBN 9781683572411
eISBN 9781683572404
ASIN B096GZL6L7 


This is the sixth volume from the pen of Shawn McAfee that I have read and I have read over 30 in the 20 Answers series. A few years ago I started with the 20 Answers Challenge when there were just 20 books in the series, at the time. I have benefited from each that I have read in the series, and have recommended many to friends and family. And each one has been educational, informative and has encouraged my faith. I have a Religious Studies Degree with a specialization in Roman Catholic Thought. I would have loved to have had these books as resources back then. They are great reads, and this is an excellent offering from Shaun McAfee. Part of the description of the volume is:

“Aren’t relics and sacramentals just “Catholic superstition”?

What are some biblical reasons for revering sacred objects and using them in prayer?

How does the Church know that body parts of saints and other holy objects are authentic?

Are there any rules for keeping relics and sacramentals at home, giving them to others, and disposing of them if necessary?

The use of holy objects in worship is one of the best-known hallmarks of Catholicism—and one of the most misunderstood. Whether it’s venerating the corporal remains or personal belongings of saints (relics) or praying with the help of tangible items in liturgy and individual devotion (sacramentals), such practices often puzzle Catholic, Protestant, and nonbeliever alike. 20 Answers: Relics and Sacramentals clears up the misconceptions and shows you how Christianity is truly an incarnational religion that involves the whole person, body and soul, and the physical world that Jesus came to redeem.”

The questions answered in this volume are:

1. What is a sacramental?
2. Is there a biblical or historical basis for sacramentals?
3. What do sacramentals do?
4. What is holy water, and what is it used for?
5. What is a scapular?
6. What are some other everyday sacramentals we encounter as Catholics?
7. What is the sign of the cross?
8. What are some examples of holy medals?
9. Don’t sacramentals like the crucifix break the First Commandment?
10. What is the proper way to treat a sacramental or dispose of it?
11. How can I use sacramentals to grow closer to God?
12. What is a relic?
13. When did the veneration of relics begin?
14. What are the different ways that relics are used in the Church?
15. How do we know that relics are genuine?
16. What are the relics of the Passion?
17. What is the Shroud of Turin?
18. Isn’t it idolatrous to worship relics?
19. Hasn’t the Church abused relics by buying and selling them?
20. How should I treat and protect relics?

The beginning of the introduction to this volume states:

“I recall the first time a non-Catholic friend asked me, “Why is Jesus still hanging on your cross? Shouldn’t the cross be a sign of victory?” The same person told me bluntly, “Your priests bow to and kiss relics, but mine worship God with their whole heart.” 

Catholics have always had to defend sacramentals and relics from attacks on the Church. History tells that pagan kings would use sacred relics as items of mockery if they overthrew a Christian city. In the Middle Ages, con artists would counterfeit saints’ blessed vestments and other relics for profit. The Protestant Reformation attacked many of the Church’s sacraments, eroding people’s respect for and recognition of sacramentals in the process. The modern Church, too, has to defend sacred relics against the “religion” of science, whose adherents dismiss as superstition whatever they can’t measure to their satisfaction in the here and now. 

It doesn’t help that at times, the same people who should have safeguarded the Church’s store of sacred relics instead gravely abused them. Catholics today have to work harder than ever to defend common sacramentals— the crucifix, holy water, pieces of the True Cross, and all the rest.”

Many of the subjects covered in this volume have entire books dedicated to them. For example Holy Water and its Significance for Catholics by Henry Theiler. But this book and this series is not intended as deep theological or spiritual works. They are quick and clean questions and answers on specific topics. And this one covering Relics & Sacramentals is a little more nebulous than some of the other volumes. An yet McAfee has done an excellent job in this book. 

When I was in university, I was involved with Campus Crusade for Christ, there was a series of booklets by the founder Bill Bright, called Transferable Concepts, and by reading them many times you could almost memorize them and the message so that you could share it. This book and this series is along those lines. You can easily work through this book in a couple of short sessions. And you could work through it a few times. And solidify the teaching in your own mind and heart. And thus be able to answer questions from non-Christians, non-Catholics and even other Catholics. 

I have benefited from all the books in this series that I have read. But to date, other than the volumes on Mary or the Papacy this is now my favourite volume. McAfee has done a wonderful job on these topics. 

Another excellent volume from McAfee and a great read in a wonderful series!

Note: This book is part of a series of reviews: 2021 Catholic Reading Plan!


...

Contributed to:
Surprised By Life: 10 Converts Explain How Catholic Teachings On Life Led Them To The Church

Inseparable: Five Perspectives on Sex, Life, and Love in Defense of Humanae Vitae 
...

20 Answers Series:
20 Answers Abortion - Trent Horn
20 Answers Angels & Demons - Fr. Mike Driscoll
20 Answers Atheism - Matt Fradd
20 Answers Death & Judgement - Trent Horn
20 Answers Divorce & Remarriage - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers End of Life - Jason Negri
20 Answers Faith & Science - Trent Horn
20 Answers God - Trent Horn
20 Answers Islam - Andrew Blezad
20 Answers Jehovah's Witnesses - Trent Horn
20 Answers Mary - Tim Staples
20 Answers Miracles - Karlo Broussard
20 Answers Mormonism - Trent Horn
20 Answers Salvation - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Scripture and Tradition - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Bible - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Eucharist - Trent Horn
20 Answers The Papacy - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Real Jesus - Trent Horn

20 Answers The Church - Trent Horn
20 Answers Witchcraft & the Occult - Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Apparitions & Revelations - Michael O'Neill
20 Answers Bible Prophecy - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Homosexuality - Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Reformation - Steve Weidenkopf
20 Answers The Sacraments - Fr. Mike Driscoll

20 Answers Bible Difficulties - Jimmy Akin  
20 Answers The Reformation - Steve Weidenkopf
20 Answers Bioethics - Stacy A. Trasancos
20 Answers Conversion - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Faith and Works - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers: Relics & Sacramentals - Shaun McAfee
20 Answers Anti-Catholic Myths - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The End Times - Jimmy Akin
20 Answers The Rosary - Tom Nash
20 Answers Seasons & Feasts – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers New Age -  Michelle Arnold
20 Answers Catholic Social Teaching – Mark Brumley
20 Answers Prayer – Hugh Barbour O. Praem and Sebastian Walshe O. Praem
20 Answers Faith & Reason – Christopher Kaczor
20 Answers The New Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Protestantism – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Marriage & Sex – Todd Aglialoro
20 Answers The Early Church – Jim Blackburn
20 Answers The Old Testament – Jimmy Akin
20 Answers Judaism – Michelle Arnold
20 Answers The Sacraments – Father Mike Driscoll
... 

Other Books from Catholic Answers:
Hard Sayings: A Catholic Approach to Answering Bible Difficulties - Trent Horn
A Daily Defense: Apologetics Lessons for Every Day - Jimmy Akin
The Apostasy That Wasn't: The Extraordinary Story of the Unbreakable Early Church - Rod Bennett
Answering Atheism - How to Make the Case for God with Logic and Charity - Trent Horn
Persuasive Pro Life: How to Talk About Our Culture's Toughest Issue - Trent Horn and Fr Frank Pavone
The Protestant's Dilemma: How the Reformation's Shocking Consequences Point to the Truth of Catholicism - Devin Rose
Behold Your Mother: A Biblical and Historical Defense of the Marian Doctrines - Tim Staples
Handed Down: The Catholic Faith of the Early Christians - James L. Papandrea
Demons, Deliverance, Discernment: Separating Fact from Fiction about the Spirit World - Fr. Mike Driscoll
Navigating the Tiber: How to Help Your Friends and Family Journey Toward the Catholic Faith - Devin Rose
100 Biblical Arguments Against Sola Scriptura - Dave Armstrong
The Drama of Salvation: How God Rescues You from Your Sins and Brings You to Eternal Life - Jimmy Akin
The Truth is Out There (Brendan and Erc in Exile Book 1 - Brother Amadeus and Amadeus
...Memorize the Reasons! Defending the Faith with the Catholic Art of Memory - Kevin Vost
Marching Orders: A Tactical Plan for Converting the World to Christ - Dan McGuire

The Fathers Know Best - Jimmy Akin
Why We're Catholic: Our Reasons for Faith, Hope, and Love - Trent Horn
The Old Evangelization: How to Spread the Faith Like Jesus Did - Eric Sammons
What the Saints Never Said - Trent Horn
...